Reading about the FDI in retail in India makes me wonder if actually the advent of the BIG wigs would wipe the small kirana shops in India. There is a 10ft by 5ft kirana shop (with a big curtain as the backdrop) near our house. The owner looks like # 3 in the 6 stage Darwin evolution theory pictures .
In his tiny shop irrespective of what you ask for he has it all and at all times.
(Not that i have ever asked for firearms to verify the completeness of his stock but i still wonder if there is tunnel connected to a supermarket behind that curtain ).
Irrespective of his looks i know running a store can be hard work, as i discovered on my first visit to "Sukriti" boutique, during a trip to Los Angles . It was delivery day and a large van was parked in front of the shop. The driver was unloading goods from the wholesale warehouse and piling them on the pavement. From here, the boxes and crates had to be carried into the store, unpacked, and their contents put on the shelves. While my cousin did the unpacking and shelving, she had hired a couple of college kids to do the heavy work of lugging the boxes into the shop. To help out, i picked up a bag of tissue and carried it in. Assuming that i too had been employed for the chore, the two kids began to pile more and more of the boxes and crates on me: C'mon, don't be so feeble and carry only two of those, take that third
box as well. Under a triple load of silk, cotton , i staggered into the shop under the direction of kids who had promoted themselves from labor to managerial supervisors: Easy now; put it down gently, don't break anything.I was carrying in my fourth — or it might have been fifth load — when Shilpa spotted me from the rear of the shop and came rushing up. She yelled at the kids. She's not the hired help; she's my sister! You're the hired help, said Shilpa. My self-appointed supervisors mumbled apologies, which i brushed aside. Sukriti was a family enterprise, in which all the family pitched in to help. And as a sister , it wasn't just my job but my pleasure to lend a hand.
Shilpa minded the till and chatted with customers as they came up to pay: How are you today, luv? Got over that nasty cold you had last week, i'm glad to see. And how's your daughter doing at university? Coming down for the holidays, is she then? Good company for you, so nice when the children come home.
This was what Sukriti — and the thousands of such across the country — had to offer which the big supermarket chains didn't: conversation and human contact, no matter how brief. Each customer was a known face, a remembered name. And in an increasingly impersonal society, where anonymity is the norm, this made all the difference.
How do you put a MRP on that.
=)
I am from Apharetta,i read your blog for the first time and i am looking to read more
ReplyDeleteits the human touch we all crave for.Nice read
ReplyDeleteHi Swati,
ReplyDeleteSomehow, I felt a shifting focus from FDI through your willingness to help through to the ending human(e) contact. Nevertheless, a nice read. Keep them posts coming :)
- Sumesh
hey swati,fun read gal i like the way you intertwine stuff..so is this fiction too ??
ReplyDeleteHey alpharetta reader !
ReplyDeletewill definitely try to be regular
@chakshu :Thanks dear :)
ReplyDelete@sumesh:I lov the way you pretend to be anonymous and then sign your name :D
@abhay: yep fiction as always :)
Well i was going to say nice take, but the cousin angle induced conflict of interest, thereby making the thought a little biased. An independent customer touched by Shilpa's gesture would have been more thought provoking.
ReplyDeleteMoreover the malls also will have humans who will interact, personalization might be the next step in line. But there needs to be a thin line, imagine u stepping into walmart ncr, and the 1st sales person greets you will GM Miss Handa. I hope you liked your last purchase of xyz.. Wish you luck for your certs to be held next month... Our records suggest you will be coming here next month, and you are due for your car maintenance also during the same time.. i guess this much personalization might scare you from coming to that place again in future.. :) n dont tell me no one gives u occasional hi @ walmsrt :P
@Abhinav: People greet me/everyone in stores but they don't know my name and i disagree with shakespeare when he said :
ReplyDelete"What's in a name? That which we call a rose
By any other name would smell as sweet."
I believe address the rose by name and it might bloom more :)
and I love the way in which you derive humor from such minute details :D:D:D
ReplyDeleteKeep them blogs coming!
- S-U-M-E-S-H
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete@SH i dont think u ll be very appreciative of everyone in WM/Kroger personalizing to those details.. :)
ReplyDeletenonetheless i got ur point.. :)
did u really carry all those boxes dear..well i wont be surprised you always are in superwoman mode to save the world :D
ReplyDeleteits interesting to go thru different perspectives..seems there are 2 things under focus - one the entire debate of FDI in retail - definitely going to be tough on competition and the other of bringing in a personal touch of a good neighbourhood store. There are 2 questions again - which offers better value/experience and the second is how relevent is it to the culture you are a part of ?
ReplyDeleteI would say both are very different to each other and have an equal right to exist after all...big stores dont sell everything on MRP..otheriwse whats the use of having them in the 1st place... end of day you cant leave such a store without getting the bill but they do have great deals however for the good neighbourhood store the key diferentiator is the longeivity of the relationship (no loyalty card required !)..incase of an uneventful morning going to buy milk/bread and forgetting your wallet at home..you can always request the shopkeeper to adjust it in the next visit..for that matter incase he doesnt have the change to return you dont mind leaving it for the next visit.
The bottomline is convienence and more importantly trust which comes uniquely to every individual and decides how one utilizes decision making in life for everything.. some do it thru the wallet, some hardwork and some thru smiles :) ..keep writing SH !!
Personally I don't mind shopping from a multi-store or a regular "small" shop as long as I know what I need to buy. Big stores attract potential buyers by offering discounts on few items while retaining higher profit margins on most of the items. You would be lucky if you really need something and it's on sale, otherwise it's just marketing and you fell prey to it!!
ReplyDeleteAnother thing I doubt is the quality of the goods sold by these big stores. "You get what you pay for". I almost never trust goods sold in BigBazar in India. My experience with Walmart remains the same. I heard many people complaining, "Walmart sells Sh**" (pardon the language).
Our society is continually becoming more complex and it's very hard for us to tell what's best for us. It should be individual choice to decide what mode suits him/her, browse for 1 hour and then wait in queue for another hour to pay or choose-(bargain)-pay with the known face at the local store.
I am not sure whether you are promoting your family business of Indian stores in the US or you are missing a personal touch in your shopping experience at Fry's, Walmart and Costco. No offence meant...
ReplyDeleteI have seen exact opposite of the examples (many instances) you cited in your blog.. especially at Fry's. Have you never been friends with the person over the counter?
@sumesh:Thanks dude!!
ReplyDelete@leena:aww..shucks..really ...geez..no way..:D
@anant:i really like the loyalty card after all a person is more than the black and white lines of a barcode :)
ReplyDelete@ankit:yo dude i hear you i see like most of us you have gone thru the pains too :(
ReplyDelete@SF1:u r back :)
ReplyDeleteinteresting tit bit" if there is a walmart nearby the property prices tend to be lower as ultimately small business shut down".I just believe in promoting small business..nothing against the big guys ..its definitely applaud worthy of how these guys must have started small and now have empires to their credit.
Yeah I get the story. So you guys will not stop promoting "Small Business (Saturday)". Just Kiddin' :-)
ReplyDelete